Skip to main content
Open

Simpler than full layer support: Surface and Item categories

Related products:NavigationFrames
Robert Johnson
mlanders
Helgos
acyment
Peter Green
+61
  • Robert Johnson
    Robert Johnson
  • mlanders
    mlanders
  • Helgos
    Helgos
  • acyment
    acyment
  • Peter Green
    Peter Green
  • Bob Hartman
  • Becky Roberts
  • Roman Makarov
  • Samuel Sun
  • Scott Bean
  • Dan Blake
  • Yachal Upson
  • JasonR
  • Guy Eckelberger
  • Krille
  • Fernanda R
  • eyalmore
  • C Mosso
  • Lars Fasten
  • RyanJ
  • Lexie Mallow
  • derekewing
  • christophe grosjean
  • Bennybanks
  • Katie Potter
  • Jennifer McAuley
  • Leonardo Márquez Juárez
  • Mallaury CREUZET
  • Cláudio de Miranda Luz
  • Mark Pearson
  • UXhebs
  • 7oshua
  • Peter Kobak
  • Luis Sierra
  • Tausif Ahmed
  • Hannah LT
  • Lukas Schreiber
  • glinero
  • Kunal Lohia
  • Dan Raymond
  • David Baird
  • Michal-Ruta
  • Antonio MS Alves
  • SantiagoGonzalezN
  • sMartin
  • Sally Tait
  • David Raffelt
  • Sergey Gridchin
  • swacsabi
  • Carel Scholtz
  • Jeff Janzen
  • bkohnke
  • Matthias Lampe
  • Jack Braun
  • FionaS
  • kkrois
  • Adam Sweetman
  • Nick Shannon
  • DHatKN
  • Gunnar Abrahamsrud
  • Philip from EverBee
  • NLP
  • Harts
  • Milton Marcelo
  • Mike Jungers
  • Igor Siqueira

Peter Green

While I would love having full Layer support with nesting and grouping and all of that jazz, a simple, whiteboard-based paradigm might be an 80/20 solution for how I’d use layers. Give us two layers for a board “Surface” (the bottom layer) and “Items” (the top layer).

 

Most of the time, what I’m doing is trying to separate things that would be the equivalent of the “surface” of the whiteboard (labels, shapes, areas, and images that I don’t expect to move), and things that are “items” on the whiteboard (sticky notes, cards, some images, that I DO expect to move around etc.). 

Working in one of the two layers would be like a Mode - CURRENTLY EDITING SURFACE or CURRENTLY EDITING ITEMS. Switching to edit one of those layers would lock the other layer, so if I am in the Items layer, I can’t do anything to the surface, it functions as a background image, and if I’m editing the surface, the items are all locked and I can’t do anything with them.

Combining this with my other request today, https://community.miro.com/wish-list-32/usage-rights-for-facilitators-vs-participants-440, facilitators could be given access to edit the surface where participants would only have access to the Items layer.

Was it helpful?

5 replies

This is one approach for solving the facilitator’s dilemma of how to allow participants to collaborate fully on a board without damaging the workshop design that has been implemented on the board before the workshop. I would love to be able to set permissions so participants could edit one layer and not another! 


Debruyne Adriaan

This would be a great feature indeed. Recently I gave a training session on how to use Miro in an educational context and a few users messed around with my board while I was presenting. Apparently I forgot to lock some of the elements. But the advantage was that I could demonstrate life that this can happen when you use Miro with students and that you should be careful with the design of your board, templates, work areas, … 

I use “Concepts” on my IPad pro to sketch. It has some great UI features Miro could benefit from. Reach out if you would like more tips or insights on this.


My understanding is that guest editors no longer have lock/unlock privileges.  That makes it possible to set up a board, lock it, then have guest editors add content without damaging the underlying board.  Thank you Miro!


Brandon Lee
Forum|alt.badge.img+1
  • Experienced Community Member
  • 103 replies
  • October 13, 2024
Peter Green wrote:

While I would love having full Layer support with nesting and grouping and all of that jazz, a simple, whiteboard-based paradigm might be an 80/20 solution for how I’d use layers. Give us two layers for a board “Surface” (the bottom layer) and “Items” (the top layer).

 

Most of the time, what I’m doing is trying to separate things that would be the equivalent of the “surface” of the whiteboard (labels, shapes, areas, and images that I don’t expect to move), and things that are “items” on the whiteboard (sticky notes, cards, some images, that I DO expect to move around etc.). 

Working in one of the two layers would be like a Mode - CURRENTLY EDITING SURFACE or CURRENTLY EDITING ITEMS. Switching to edit one of those layers would lock the other layer, so if I am in the Items layer, I can’t do anything to the surface, it functions as a background image, and if I’m editing the surface, the items are all locked and I can’t do anything with them.

Combining this with my other request today, https://community.miro.com/wish-list-32/usage-rights-for-facilitators-vs-participants-440, facilitators could be given access to edit the surface where participants would only have access to the Items layer.

@Peter Green wouldn’t a Group Select (Drag Mouse or Ctrl + a) of your “Protected Objects” and sending them to a Locked Layer while using a 2nd Layer for editing be the same workflow?

The one Feature Request I would like is to have a Lock Option where only the Board Owner (or Designated Team Member) be allowed to Unlock the Layer.

 


ElvaMiro
Mironeer
Forum|alt.badge.img+2
  • Mironeer
  • 922 replies
  • October 14, 2024

Thanks for your thoughtful feedback, @Brandon Lee. We appreciate these insights.